Serving Sacramento, Placer, Yolo and El Dorado counties · A person answers, 24 hours a day Office Monday to Friday, 9 AM to 5 PM · Care staffed around the clock · Toll free 1-877-671-5692
Guiding Souls Home Care, Sacramento
Questions families ask

Private caregiver or agency: which is better in California?

An agency is the better choice if your mother needs help each morning and you cannot cover a missed shift.

Rather ask a person? Tell us what is happening at home and we will tell you what applies to you. (916) 229-8120

  • Free in-home assessment
  • A person answers, 24 hours a day
  • Sacramento, Placer, Yolo and El Dorado counties

By Mereani Blanton Published 6 minute read

Two wooden chairs with teal pillows and a small table with a terracotta-colored book and pen sit on a patio overlooking a landscape of valley oaks.

The short answer

An agency is the better choice if your mother needs help each morning and you cannot cover a missed shift. Hiring privately fits better if you can manage payroll and have someone ready to cover absences. Ask each agency how it handles hiring and schedules, especially when a caregiver calls in sick. A private caregiver can cost less per hour, but you become the employer, and the paperwork and the backup plan are yours.

  • An agency is usually easier if you want someone else to handle backup, payroll and paperwork, and a private caregiver costs less per hour only if you are ready to be the employer.
  • If you hire privately in California, you are the employer, so you owe at least $16.90 an hour in 2026 and overtime past 9 hours in a day or 45 in a week for a personal attendant.
  • Check any aide you find on the state's Home Care Aide Registry, which shows whether a background check was done.
  • If your parent has Medi-Cal and is 65 or older, ask the county about In-Home Supportive Services (IHSS) before you spend savings.
  • Ask every option the same three questions: who covers a sick day, what is the total cost in writing, and who is in charge when something goes wrong.

Published by Guiding Souls Home Care, Inc., a family owned non-medical home care agency at 3626 Fair Oaks Blvd, Suite 100, Sacramento, CA 95864, serving Sacramento, Placer, Yolo and El Dorado counties in California. Call (916) 229-8120, answered by a person 24 hours a day.

On this page On this page
  1. How do a private caregiver and an agency differ?
  2. When is each option the right choice?
  3. What does it cost, and who can help pay?
  4. What happens if you call Guiding Souls Home Care?

Say your mother in Sacramento needs help getting up, dressed and fed, and you work all day. Or your husband can no longer be left alone after lunch. You need someone steady, and you need to know what happens when that person wakes up sick. Guiding Souls Home Care does not provide home health, skilled nursing or hospice. Guiding Souls Home Care does not provide assisted living either.

How do a private caregiver and an agency differ?

Before hiring, confirm who will be the caregiver's employer.

With a private caregiver, you are. California treats a family that hires directly as the employer, as the Domestic Worker Bill of Rights FAQ explains. That means a wage at or above the state minimum, which is $16.90 an hour for all employers from January 1, 2026. It also means overtime at 1.5 times the regular rate for a personal attendant (someone who mainly supervises, feeds and dresses) after 9 hours in a day or 45 in a week. Payroll taxes and workers' compensation are on you as well, so ask an accountant or payroll service what applies.

With an agency, the agency is the employer. You pay the agency, and it pays the caregiver.

  • Sick days: a private caregiver who is ill leaves you with a gap, often at short notice. An agency can send someone else.
  • Ask who answers calls at night or on weekends, whether you hire privately or use an agency.
  • Hiring: you write the ad, meet people and check references. An agency does the screening.
  • Control: a private caregiver may feel more personal, and you choose exactly who comes.

When is each option the right choice?

Hire privately if you have time, a relative or friend you already trust, and a plan for the days the caregiver cannot come. It also works when needs are small, such as a few hours twice a week.

Use an agency if your parent needs care most days, if you live far away, or if you cannot be the backup yourself. It also fits if you do not want to run payroll.

Some families mix them. A cousin covers weekends, and an agency covers weekdays.

An agency can also be the wrong fit. If your parent qualifies for IHSS and wants a family member paid as the provider, that is a county program, not an agency job.

Whoever you choose, look the person up. The Home Care Aide Registry shows whether an aide completed the criminal background check run by the California Department of Social Services. To check an agency, use the Care Facility Search and pick the type Home Care Organization to see its licence number and status.

What does it cost, and who can help pay?

In the Sacramento-Roseville-Folsom area, the CareScout 2025 Cost of Care Survey puts the median non-medical caregiver at $40 an hour, or $7,627 a month at 44 hours a week. At the survey's local $40 hourly median, 20 hours a week works out to about $3,467 a month: $40 times 20 hours times 52 weeks, divided by 12 months. The same survey lists assisted living locally at $7,750 a month.

Those are medians for agencies and the market, so a private caregiver may ask for less. Add payroll tax, overtime and the cost of covering sick days before you compare.

Check eligibility for public help before setting a private care budget. In-Home Supportive Services pays for in-home help for people on Medi-Cal who are 65 or older, blind or disabled. You apply through the county, and a social worker visits to decide how many hours to authorize. If approved, your parent hires the provider and is the employer. Medi-Cal has an asset limit of $130,000 for one person through June 30, 2027. The home and one car do not count.

If your parent is a veteran or a surviving spouse, VA Aid and Attendance adds a monthly payment to a VA pension for people who need help with daily activities.

If you are cutting back work to care for a parent, Paid Family Leave gives up to 8 weeks of partial pay.

See All home care services for what non-medical care covers, and Where We Serve, Sacramento Region for the towns around you.

What happens if you call Guiding Souls Home Care?

First, write down the help needed and the hours someone must be there. Next, call with that list. Before agreeing to care, ask who employs the caregiver, what the full cost includes and who covers a missed shift.

A person answers (916) 229-8120 at any hour, including weekends and holidays. The first visit to the house is free and carries no obligation. Mereani Blanton does it herself on most new cases, looks at the routine and the layout, and puts a plan and a clear cost in writing before anything begins. There is no contract, and a caregiver is only assigned once the match is right. You can also schedule a free assessment online.

Questions families ask

Questions families ask about private caregivers and agencies

If yours is not here, ask it on the phone: (916) 229-8120.

What happens when a private caregiver gets sick?

You cover the shift or go without. Ask any caregiver you hire how much notice they will give, and line up a backup before you need one. Ask the agency whether a replacement is available and whether your parent can meet that person before a shift needs covering.

Can a family member be paid to care for my parent?

Sometimes. Through IHSS, a relative can be the paid provider if your parent is approved. Start with your county's IHSS office.

Is a caregiver found online safe to hire?

Not automatically. Meet them in person, call references and check the Home Care Aide Registry. Agree on duties and pay in writing before the first shift.

Can a non-medical caregiver give my father his pills?

No. At Guiding Souls Home Care, a caregiver reminds about medication and does not give it. If he needs more than reminders, ask his doctor about skilled care at home.

Keep reading

The guides behind this answer

Paying for care

How to pay for home care in Sacramento, California

Most families arrive believing Medicare covers this. It does not. The program that does is Medi-Cal, and it has its own application and its own gate. Here is every source of money there is, in the words of the agencies that run them.

Read the guide
Choosing an agency

How to choose a home care agency in Sacramento

Most agency websites in this region say the same eleven things. Here is what actually differs between them, which of it you can verify without asking, and the questions worth asking out loud.

Read the guide

See all ten home care services

Tell us what is happening at home

One call, at any hour, and a free visit before anything is decided. No contract, and a caregiver only once the match is right.

Looking for caregiving work?

We hire for character and train the rest through our Training Academy. Tell us about yourself.

See open roles